Sarah Michelle Gellar Works Missoni in New York

Wearing a Missoni Fall 2025 oversized white wool plaid coat with a coordinating mini skirt, Gellar gave off what can only be described as an Upper East Side energy—think gallery opening meets power lunch. Her accessories were equally luxe: a Balenciaga Tote Rodeo Bag nestled in her arm, Christian Louboutin Iriza pumps on her feet, and a hint of glam from Alexis Bittar’s Liquid Lucite Hoop Earrings in gold.

Still, fashion followers were left conflicted. Once the coat came off inside the studio, the silhouette lost some of its strength. The mini skirt’s proportion felt slightly off-balance, and the choice of nude pumps over black or bold yellow raised a few brows among trend-watchers.

Nonetheless, Gellar’s presence reignited buzz around two iconic reboots—Buffy the Vampire Slayer and I Know What You Did Last Summer—making this outing as much about media nostalgia as it was about style.

What do you think of Sarah Michelle Gellar’s fashion evolution? Is her shift toward structured classics a trend to watch, or simply a nostalgic nod? Sound off below—we’d love to hear your take!